Sample work
See exactly what you will receive
Three samples built on a real US patent, exact claim text and real prior art. Products and inventions in Samples 2 and 3 are hypothetical.
Sample 1: Invalidity search on US 8,560,031 B2, claim 9
Medium risk to patenteeClaim 9 (PopSockets LLC) is open to a §103 challenge over Touzani US 4,955,493 A in view of Wang US 5,568,549 A.
| Claim 9 element (verbatim, abridged) | D1: US 4,955,493 (Touzani, 1990) | D2: US 5,568,549 (Wang, 1996) | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| [pre] "A socket for attaching to a portable media player…" | Household container / lamp stand | "mobile telephone holder" | Disclosed by D2 |
| [a] "a securing element for attaching the socket to the back of the portable media player…" | Suction cup 150 / 170 joined to base 102 | "vacuum mounts 118" on mounting base | Partly disclosed |
| [b] "an accordion forming a tapered shape… collapsing generally along its axis" | "circular bellows" of "conical sections"; covers "conical-shaped" articles | Bellows tube 22, bendable | Disclosed by D1 |
| [c] "a foot disposed at the distal end of the accordion." | Top 101 at the free end | Holder frame 3 at the free end | Arguable |
Next step: search art not of record. Both references were cited during prosecution, so a stronger challenge needs new art.
Sample 2: FTO for a telescoping phone grip vs US 8,560,031 B2
AmberThe product avoids claim 1 and likely avoids claim 9 literally; claim 22 (means-plus-function) and equivalents leave real exposure.
| Claim | Deciding claim language (verbatim) | Client product (hypothetical) | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 (case) | "a case body for housing the portable media player" | Stick-on grip; no case body | Green |
| 9 (socket) | "an accordion forming a tapered shape connected to the securing element" | Rigid telescoping tubes; straight, not tapered | Amber |
| 22 (means-plus-function) | "means for extending the socket outward generally along its axis… by collapsing the socket" | Telescoping extends and retracts along the axis | Amber |
Recommendation: keep the telescoping design, do not bundle a case, and obtain a US attorney FTO opinion before scaling inventory.
Sample 3: Patentability of a phone grip with cord winder
Not novel as describedFeatures 1–3 are already claimed in US 8,560,031 B2. Only feature 4 remains open to patent.
| Invention feature (hypothetical) | Closest prior art (verbatim claim text) | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Adhesive pad on the phone back | US 8,560,031 claim 15: "the securing element comprises suction-cup tape." | Found |
| 2. Collapsible accordion grip | Claim 16: "an accordion forming a tapered shape and having walls interspaced with flexural hinges" | Found |
| 3. Cord wound around the grips | Claim 20: "winding a cord around the accordions after extending the sockets and before retracting the sockets." | Found |
| 4. Magnetic lock for the cord end | Not found in US 8,560,031, US 4,955,493 or US 5,568,549 | Open |
Advice: claim around feature 4 only, after a wider search of magnetic cable organisers and grip accessories.
Sources: US 8,560,031 B2, US 4,955,493 A, US 5,568,549 A (Google Patents). Samples are research and technical analysis, not legal opinions. Full reports are available on request.
Want a sample in your technology?
Ask for a redacted sample in your sector during your scoping call.