Prior art to challenge a patent

Patent invalidity search with prior art claim charts

Facing an assertion or preparing an IPR? We find prior art that can defeat the asserted claims, including art the examiner never saw, and deliver charts your counsel can use.

The question

Can this patent be knocked out?

Facing an assertion or preparing an IPR? We find prior art that can defeat the asserted claims, including art the examiner never saw, and deliver charts your counsel can use.

Who it is for

  • Patent litigation law firms
  • Companies that have received a demand letter
  • IPR, PGR and opposition teams
  • Licensing teams assessing patent strength

When to use it

On receiving a demand letter, before litigation, IPR / PGR filings or European oppositions, or before acquiring or licensing a patent.

Our protocol

How we run your Invalidity Search

Six steps, the same on every project, so you always know where your work stands.

  1. Claim analysis

    Target claims are split into elements and key terms are construed.

  2. Date check

    Priority and effective filing dates are confirmed to set the prior-art cut-off.

  3. File history

    Prosecution history and art of record are reviewed so we search beyond it.

  4. Global search

    Patents and non-patent literature worldwide, including standards, manuals and archived web pages.

  5. Mapping

    References are mapped to each element; strongest 102 / 103 combinations are built.

  6. Charts & review

    Claim charts with pinpoint citations, checked by a second analyst.

Deliverables

What you receive

  • Ranked prior art: patents and non-patent literature
  • 102 / 103 (novelty / obviousness) combinations with rationale
  • Element-by-element invalidity claim charts (Word and Excel)
  • Priority and effective-date analysis
  • Search log for counsel
Fast answer

Essential

  • Top prior-art set
  • Claim-to-art mapping
Most complete

Enhanced

  • Broader coverage incl. NPL
  • Stronger 102 / 103 combinations
  • Full invalidity claim charts
Sample

Sample 1: Invalidity search on US 8,560,031 B2, claim 9

Medium risk to patenteeClaim 9 (PopSockets LLC) is open to a §103 challenge over Touzani US 4,955,493 A in view of Wang US 5,568,549 A.
Claim 9 element (verbatim, abridged)D1: US 4,955,493 (Touzani, 1990)D2: US 5,568,549 (Wang, 1996)Status
[pre] "A socket for attaching to a portable media player…"Household container / lamp stand"mobile telephone holder"Disclosed by D2
[a] "a securing element for attaching the socket to the back of the portable media player…"Suction cup 150 / 170 joined to base 102"vacuum mounts 118" on mounting basePartly disclosed
[b] "an accordion forming a tapered shape… collapsing generally along its axis""circular bellows" of "conical sections"; covers "conical-shaped" articlesBellows tube 22, bendableDisclosed by D1
[c] "a foot disposed at the distal end of the accordion."Top 101 at the free endHolder frame 3 at the free endArguable

Next step: search art not of record. Both references were cited during prosecution, so a stronger challenge needs new art.

FAQ

Invalidity Search: common questions

What is a patent invalidity search?

An invalidity (invalidation) search looks for prior art published before a patent's priority date that discloses, or makes obvious, the elements of its claims. It is used to challenge a patent in court, at the PTAB or in oppositions.

Do you search beyond the art of record?

Yes. Art already considered by the examiner is weaker, so we prioritise new art and non-patent literature.

What format are the claim charts in?

Word and Excel, with exact claim language and pinpoint citations (figure, column, line or paragraph) to each reference.

Can you meet a court or PTAB deadline?

Yes. Tell us the deadline at scoping; rush delivery is available.

Are reports white-label?

Yes. Reports are unbranded by default so law firms can integrate them into their own work product.

Need help with Invalidity Search?

Tell us what you need. You receive a scope, a fixed quote and a delivery date, usually within hours.

Get a quote